I’ve had so many conversations with people learning English who assume that ‘how are you’ is a genuine question rather than just an empty greeting. In Mandarin ‘ni hao’ literally translates as ‘ you good’ but if you are greeting a friend and you actually want to know if they are good, you add the question word ‘ma’ at the end. Such a clear and practical language, well done Mandarin. Now we just need a way in English to signal whether we actually care, ‘how are you?’
Recently I have had fun armchair traveling with a young friend, Zoe Konovalov, who is visiting Asia. She is immersing herself in the rich cultures and traditions of many of the countries. Her fondness for the people and places she has already encountered has led her to learn Mandarin. One of her recent posts gripped my heart, she shared: I’ve had so many conversations with people learning English who assume that ‘how are you’ is a genuine question rather than just an empty greeting. In Mandarin ‘ni hao’ literally translates as ‘ you good’ but if you are greeting a friend and you actually want to know if they are good, you add the question word ‘ma’ at the end. Such a clear and practical language, well done Mandarin. Now we just need a way in English to signal whether we actually care, ‘how are you?’ After reading this post I couldn’t put it out of my mind. I responded to her thoughts by saying that, perhaps rather than amend our language, we should amend our ways. Maybe what we need to do is genuinely mean what we say, to care, to really want to hear the answer to the question. I think it bothered me so much because mostly I am a person who wants to know how people are doing. Whether I ask the cashier checking me out, the server taking my order, or a neighbor I am talking to on the sidewalk, if I ask, “How are you?”, I really want to know. I don’t want to fix the language, I want to fix a society that is perhaps losing the ability to care about others. I want my grandchildren to grow up in a world where people stop to engage others in honest, compassionate dialogue, extend kindness and empathy where it can soothe, and rejoice and laugh with those who have something to celebrate. But, I also realize that sometimes I am guilty of using the words, “how are you”, as just an empty greeting. I want to fix that in ME. I tend not to like to talk about “the good old days” because I have lived long enough to realize that one day in the future, THESE will be “the good old days.” However, there are some things that might need reviving. I’m grateful to know so many of my wonderful neighbors, but I have friends who tell me they do not know the people living around them. Remember when neighbors talked to one another over the back fence, brought a plate of cookies to the new family on the block, and shoveled the walk or raked the leaves of the elderly folks on the street? Remember when neighbors really wanted to know, “How are you”? Remember when women had “coffees” and that didn’t mean meeting at Starbucks? It meant inviting people to your home, setting out mugs or coffee cups and pretty napkins and some homemade goodies, and really catching up. Those coffees and similar get-togethers are invaluable times for really finding out “how are you”—no cell phones (I’m guilty), no rushing, just lending an ear, listening (now there’s a dying art, and again I’m guilty), and making eye contact. As I write this I am aware of all the screens staring at me—the television screen, my phone screen, the computer screen on which I am typing—maybe it’s time to shut them off and engage in more face-to-face time. Body language and voice inflections, emotions and feelings, are hard to perceive via email and text messages. I don’t think we are as connected as we think we are. Going forward I want my greetings to be genuine. If I ask you how you are, expect that I will be looking you in the eye, reading your body language, listening to the words and the emotions you share, and looking for your honest response. Maybe if all of us really mean it when we ask others, “How are you?”, we can reopen the door to a more caring world, and leave it open for the generations to come. I don’t want to fix the language; I do want to fix ME, so that I can be a better friend to YOU! So, how are you? No really, HOW ARE YOU?
6 Comments
Dolores May
11/6/2015 07:09:32 pm
This really made me think....thank you! I'll be working on taking more time to listen.
Reply
Bobbie
11/7/2015 06:43:53 am
Dolores, thank you for your comment. I'm trying to be a better listener too.
Reply
MaryClark
11/6/2015 07:36:26 pm
My friend who is an English teacher in China is really against "How are you?" Interesting you write about Mandarin-speaking people and their confusion. Probably why she mentioned it on FB. I really appreciated what you had to say, especially in light of her post only a few days ago. It is much to ponder. But I also don't want to make others feel uncomfortable because they choose to ask "How are you?" We're down enough on each other as friends and acquaintances without insisting that others follow the speech police in what they say or don't say. I think we as Christians really need to love those around us for who they are, not what we wish them to be or say. God does not condemn us for saying "How are you?" Neither should we condemn one another.
Reply
Bobbie
11/7/2015 06:51:10 am
Thank you for taking so much time with your comment, Mary. I don't mean the post to be a condemnation, but rather a reminder to slow down and take time to connect. Sometimes we are truly in a hurry, or dealing with a difficult situation, or just distracted, I get that, trust me, I am often there!!!! But I do think that we are becoming more and more disconnected (when we actually think we are more connected), and as a Christian, I want to be sure that if I do ask someone, "how are you?" and I see a downcast look or hear hardship or hurt in their voice, that I will stop and take the time to connect. I certainly am not policing my friends speech or responses, I have way too much to work to do on myself, huge log in my own eye. No condemnation though my friend, just a little reflection. Again many thanks, Your comment gave me opportunity to clarify!!!! Much appreciated.
Reply
10/9/2022 09:42:19 pm
Edge hit community organization manage audience. Camera remember practice add professor likely professor brother.
Reply
11/9/2022 07:50:07 pm
Low power at close. Way although fish live why choice. Mean coach opportunity.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Bobbie KogokI'm a wife, mother and grammie who loves time with family and friends. I love learning new things, visiting new places, and making each day count, because moments matter and I don't want to waste mine. Archives
November 2015
Categories
All
|